Who Are The Best Colorado Buffaloes Players That Can Join Shedeur Sanders In NFL Next Season?

June 11, 2025 by Staff

Colorado Buffalo fans certainly remember their time with Shedeur Sanders fondly. The former quarterback transferred in from Jackson State University and set multiple school records in the 2024 season.

Passing yards. Completions. Attempts. Touchdowns. Completion percentage. Quarterback rating. Just recently, in the 2025 NFL Draft, he was selected 144th overall by the Cleveland Browns.

He was anticipated as a higher pick, but that certainly won't get him down. Shedeur is working hard to make a name for himself as he develops his presence in the NFL.

He leaves behind a very capable Colorado Buffaloes team in his wake. The team still has a strong leadership structure in place, and this is the sort of team that can attract a lot of great talent through the transfer portal.

If you are interested in a far too early YouBet.com recommendation, they are at least worth paying attention to.

Thanks to his brash personality and family name, Shedeur Sanders got a lot of press. What you might not know? He was one of several players drafted from the Buffaloes. In fact, one of his teammates was picked MUCH earlier than he was. What other Buffaloes are heading to the NFL?

Travis Hunter

Shedeur Sanders might have gotten most of the attention for his big personality and football royalty lineage, but Travis Hunter actually had a much better experience with the draft.

The cornerback was picked second overall by the Jacksonville Jaguars. It was a well-earned position. He's a noted two-way player who had great success at the college level, winning the Heisman Trophy in 2024.

He was also a two-time All-American pick. Hunter is versatile, productive, and expected to excel in the NFL, which sort of begs the question: Is Travis Hunter joining Shedeur Sanders in the NFL, or is Shedeur Sanders joining Travis Hunter? That’s a topic we’ll leave to wiser writers.

LeJantay Wester

Wide receiver LeJantay Wester was picked by the Baltimore Ravens in the 6th round. While he found his way into the NFL even later than Shedeur Sanders, he’s certainly positioned for a potentially remarkable career. He’s always been an underdog. He started off as a zero-star recruit.

From there, he found his way to Florida Atlantic. There, he broke several receiving records in 2023. He continued to perform well in Colorado.

While he might not have attracted much buzz, a player with this level of grit can accomplish a lot, even when people aren’t necessarily expecting it from him.

Jimmy Horn

Jimmy Horn Jr. is a wide receiver. He began his college career at South Florida, playing for two seasons. He finished out with two more years at the Buffaloes. There, he collected 95 receptions, 1,008 receiving yards, and 7 touchdowns.

Noted for his speed, agility, and general grit, Jimmy Horn Jr. is a passionate player who is sure to bring his unique playing style to the NFL. At 5'8" and only 174 pounds, he's smaller than most wide receivers, but that's never stopped him from finding success.

Horn was drafted in the 6th round and will be making his professional debut for the Panthers.

Undrafted Free Agents

There are also several players who were not selected in the draft but have the option to enter the NFL as undrafted free agents. These players include Shiloh Sanders, Cam'ron Silmon-Craig, Will Sheppard, and B.J. Green II.

An undrafted free agent is a player who went unselected during the seven rounds of the draft but can still sign with any team willing to give them a shot.

While the road is steeper, undrafted players often use training camp and preseason to prove their worth—and many have carved out impressive NFL careers. Kurt Warner and Tony Romo are favorite examples of undrafted players who went on to big things. However, there are many others with notable achievements.

Remember—anyone who plays professional football is really, really good. Often, collegiate experiences paint an imperfect picture of NFL potential.

What will these guys do when they get there?

That’s the real question. Getting in is great. To stick around, you need to produce results. Shedeur Sanders himself is a good example of how the hype around a college player doesn’t necessarily translate into professional interest.

Now, the reason why he was drafted later than expected is a little more nuanced and is probably not relevant to the other players on this list.

There were personal issues that distracted from his draft position. All of that said, you never really know what will happen with a college player — in terms of both how they will experience the NFL Draft, and what they will do once they get to the big leagues. Still, it's fun to guess, isn't it?